Nottoway Plantation in White Castle, Louisiana, is under scrutiny as the community and historians debate its complex history and current use. The antebellum estate, known for its Greek Revival architecture, has been a popular wedding venue, but its reliance on enslaved African Americans has sparked controversy. The plantation, once home to John Hampden Randolph and his family, was built and maintained by enslaved people, a fact that has raised concerns about the narrative presented by the plantation’s management.

Critics argue that the focus on the Randolph family’s lifestyle overlooks the suffering and contributions of the enslaved. In response, Nottoway’s management, led by Cary McMillin, has partnered with historians to develop new exhibits and tours that address the lives of the enslaved. However, some argue that these efforts are insufficient and that the plantation should more substantially acknowledge the injustices of its past.

The use of Nottoway as a wedding and event venue is a particularly contentious issue, with some arguing that it is insensitive to celebrate joyful occasions on a site associated with profound suffering. Online petitions have garnered significant support, calling for a re-evaluation of the venue’s purpose. McMillin maintains that the revenue from events is necessary to preserve the historic structure and fund further historical research.

The debate surrounding Nottoway reflects a broader trend across the South, where historic sites are grappling with how to present their complex histories. Local organizations, such as the River Road Historical Society, are hosting community forums to discuss these issues and foster a more inclusive understanding of Louisiana’s past. As the community continues to discuss Nottoway’s role, it is clear that the plantation is entering a period of significant reflection and potential change, driven by a growing demand for a more truthful and equitable reckoning with the legacy of slavery.