Blake Lively’s silence on a potential *A Simple Favor* sequel has long fueled fan speculation. However, recent activity from director Paul Feig has reignited hopes for a follow-up. Feig posted a cryptic message on social media featuring a martini glass, a symbol closely associated with Lively’s character Stephanie, accompanied by the caption “Hmm… maybe…”. The post quickly sent the internet into a frenzy, with #ASimpleFavor2 trending on Twitter and TikTok. Although Lively and Anna Kendrick haven’t directly commented on Feig’s post, the visual cue is being interpreted as a strong hint that discussions are underway. The 2018 film, based on Darcey Bell’s novel, captivated audiences with its plot twists, stylish aesthetic, and the chemistry between Lively and Kendrick. Despite reports of a sequel being discussed since 2019, progress stalled due to scheduling complexities and script development. Feig previously cited the difficulty in aligning Lively and Kendrick’s schedules as a significant hurdle. Industry insiders suggest that Lionsgate, the studio behind *A Simple Favor*, is exploring options and potentially pitching new script ideas to the stars. The recent success of neo-noir thrillers has contributed to renewed interest in revisiting the universe and characters. Fans are eager to see the continuation of Stephanie and Erin’s ambiguous relationship and to unravel further mysteries surrounding Lively’s character. The original film’s ending left room for a continuation, and its enduring popularity suggests a dedicated audience ready for a second installment, with social media currently flooded with fan theories and desired plot points. While everything remains speculative, Feig’s social media tease has generated significant buzz and momentum around the possibility of another chapter for Stephanie and Erin.